is thousand island dressing keto

Is Thousand Island Dressing Keto?

In this article, I will provide answers to the frequently asked question “is thousand island dressing keto-friendly or not?” Also, I will explain homemade thousand island dressing recipes and a thousand island dressing purchased at the store.

Which one is keto-friendly so you can understand how to enjoy this recipe while maintaining your keto diet.

Homemade Thousand Island Dressing Recipe

is thousand island dressing keto

The homemade thousand island dressing recipe is a popular sweet and tangy salad that has been in the kitchen for some time. Its popularity is because it requires only a few ingredients and takes a short time to make.

But though it’s sweet, it is keto, low-carb, and sugar-free. It is very healthy and is ideal for people who are trying to lose weight.

The Origin of the Homemade Thousand Island Dressing Recipe

There are many stories which detail the origins of the Homemade Thousand Island Dressing recipe.

However, this recipe’s name is derived from the Thousand Islands in Northern New York, but there is no clear information on the creator of this recipe.

I have eggs in this recipe because it was used in the past to make thick sauces. Though most people don’t like adding eggs to this meal, it adds flavor to the meal.

It can also be frozen a little, but it will start to change texture when you freeze it for more than one month.

Ingredients in the Homemade Thousand Island Dressing Recipe

The thousand island dressing is prepared from mayonnaise, ketchup, sweet pickles, red pepper, onion, and garlic. If you want to keep it keto, it’s best to avoid sugary sweet pickles and sugar ketchup.

Also, add some hard-boiled eggs to make it more keto. The ingredients are:

  1. Mayonnaise – Though there is the store-bought avocado oil mayo, you can also prepare it from home.
  2. Sugar Free Ketchup.
  3. Apple Cider Vinegar – Besides the apple cider vinegar, white vinegar is also a good ingredient.
  4. Keto Sweetener– I would recommend you to use the powdered keto sweetener as they dissolve better.
  5. Dick pickles– Just ensure it doesn’t contain sugar.
  6. Minced onion

How to Prepare the Homemade Thousand Island recipe

is thousand island dressing keto

Making the homemade thousand island recipe is not a daunting task. Follow the instructions below:

  1. Combine the Ingredients- First, mix all ingredients in a small bowl. Add the mayonnaise first, then the ketchup, apple cider vinegar and keto sweetener. Finally, add the finely chopped dill pickles, diced white onion, and salt and black pepper to taste. Mix these ingredients to combine. Ensure you make more than you need as they get deplete fast
  2. Store the extra in an airtight container. Once the food is ready, you can serve it immediately or refrigerate it for future use.

I would also recommend you prepare the ingredients in advance to allow the flavors to blend better. Though it’s not a necessity, it will help the food to maintain a good taste. Also, use finely diced onions and unsweetened ketchup.

The sugar-free ketchup is usually sweetened, and you won’t need to add more sugar to the recipe.

What should you serve the Homemade Thousand Islands dressing with?

is thousand island dressing keto

After the Homemade thousand island dressing is ready, you will have some ideas for serving it. I will recommend adding it to your favorite keto salads, but you can also use it as a special sauce or spread for your sandwiches and keto burgers.

Additionally, I love using it as a dip for my burritos, tacos, and wraps. And if you want to make your own Big Mac Sauces, it will be a great ingredient.

How to Store the Recipe

The best way of storing this recipe is by keeping it in a squeeze bottle or airtight container. After you remove it from the container, you should store it in the refrigerator until you use it.

But don’t keep it in the fridge for more than a week. But when using a freezer, it can keep it in good condition for up to 3 months.

Why this Meal is a Favorite for Many

The homemade salad dressing has a better taste and is ideal for you. And looking at this keto recipe, it never disappoints and doesn’t require much effort to prepare.

Besides, it does not involve any whisking or food processing, as you only need to add ingredients to a bowl and mix them.

Alternatively, you can spread or pour this meal into your favorite keto carbs. It is a classic American recipe that is sweet and tangy. It’s best for burgers, but the store-bought dressings usually contain some sugar servings.

You should make your own Thousand Island Dressing and use sweeteners instead of real sugars. This will help you to reduce the number of carbs in the meal.

Buy Thousand Island Dressing at The Shop

Is Thousand Island Dressing Keto?

You can buy it on

Is Store-Bought Thousand Island Dressing Keto Friendly?

Unfortunately, the thousand island dressing that can be purchased at the store is not keto because of some carbs. This isn’t good for people on a diet who are looking to lose weight. Below are the reasons why it’s, not a good keto meal:

  1. Too Many Carbs. Unlike most keto meals, the Thousand Island contains too many carbs. Therefore, you need to avoid it because it has an average of 13.33 g per 100 ml serving. I would advise you to limit your consumption of carbs from 20g to 30g a day to remain in ketosis mode. Therefore, try other salad dressing with lower levels of carbs.
  2. Contains Soybean Oil. Soybean oil is a highly refined oil that oxidizes easily and may cause inflammation in your body. It is extracted under chemicals and high heat, and this process usually removes beneficial nutrients and puts harmful chemicals instead. When on a keto diet, you should always stick to healthy sources of fats to ensure your body burns clean fuel during this process. And soybean oil is not an ingredient that should feature anywhere in your keto diet.
  3. It has Sugar. Sugar is a sweetener that may prevent you from your keto goals. Therefore, you need to find other alternative salad dressing brands which have sweeteners such as monk fruit, erythritol, and stevia. These are keto-friendly options for your meals.

Minimizing the Carbs in Thousand Island Dressing

Though Thousand Island dressing is not the ideal keto recipe, you can lower the content of the carbs by using Rotel in this meal. Avoid using tomato sauce or ketchup, as it will increase the amount of carbs in this thousand island dressing.

Also, use the rotel chunks and not the liquid. Using too much liquid will make the sauce too runny than when you don’t.

Alternatives to Thousand Island Dressing

1. Russian Dressing

Is Thousand Island Dressing Keto?

You can buy it on

The best alternative to the Thousand Island dressing is the Russian dressing. But despite its name, it is not Russian, and it is rumored that it originated from Hampshire.

Many people confuse this meal with Thousand island because they look similar and use the same ingredients.

The main ingredients in this recipe are ketchup and mayonnaise, which are common in the Thousand Island dressing. But the initial versions contained caviar where the Russian name likely originated.

Additionally, the original Russian dressing also contained pickles which was a popular ingredient in most Russian immigrants. This ingredient is also found in the Thousand island recipe.

The Russian dressing is spicier compared to the Thousand Island Dressing because it includes chili pepper and horseradish ingredients. But it has celery seed as an additional ingredient not found in the former.

2. Ranch Dressing

Is Thousand Island Dressing Keto?

You can buy it on

Compared to the Thousand Island dressing, the ranch is still newer in the market, but they share some properties. It is usually tangy because mayonnaise forms a major component of the recipe. It also gives it an extra creamy feel like the Thousand Island dressing.

But this recipe has more seasonings than the Thousand Islands recipe, but most don’t have sugar. Therefore, they are not so sweet as the flavors common in Thousand island variations.

It is one of the best alternatives, but it has mayonnaise and sour cream, which raises high saturated fat content levels. But you can find ways of reducing this content and make it keto-friendly.

3. French Dressing

Is Thousand Island Dressing Keto?

You can buy it on

French dressing is a tangy recipe that is better than most recipes you can buy from the store. I would recommend you make it at home instead of going to the store. For starters, most store-bought French dressing tastes awful and so why should you buy it?

Besides, you will be buying food that is high in sugar and saturated fats. When you make it from home, you can regulate the ingredients to suit your dieting and fitness needs.

The French Dressing is a dream recipe, and you will find it in most Greek restaurants today.

Additionally, it takes a short time to put the ingredients together, and you may already be owning these ingredients in your kitchen. When preparing it for the Dorito Taco Salad, you don’t need to use all the ingredients.

But you can also make plenty of French Dressing because it can remain fresh in the refrigerator for up to 4 days.

4. Green Goddess

Is Thousand Island Dressing Keto?

You can buy it on

This recipe is a California Classic and is an incredible dressing for lettuces and a good dip for crudites. However, when making spring mixes, it’s not ideal because it’s too intense.

Therefore, you should not add anchovies because they increase the depth of the flavor. And if you don’t like salt, then don’t add it.

This is one of my most favorite delicious sauces and dip. If you want to adjust the acidity levels, then use some lemons and add pepper and salt but don’t interfere with the chive, parsley, and sweet tarragon. They give it a unique taste.

5. Marie Rose Sauce

Is Thousand Island Dressing Keto?

You can buy it on

Marie Rose sauce is also known as seafood sauce or cocktail sauce in some areas. It is of British origin and is made from mayonnaise, tomatoes, black pepper, lemon juice, and Worcestershire sauce.

But you can also make a basic version using mayonnaise and tomato ketchup. Fanny Cradock, a celebrity chef, is widely known for popularizing this sauce back in the 1960s.

It can be served with prawns and other seafood, and its history also dates back earlier. Though there are variations, the 1967 version by Fanny Cradock is the most popular.

Some variations include the Constance Spry, which includes sweetened tomato pulp and mayonnaise; it is commonly used when preparing the prawn cocktail.

The Constance Spry is a ketchup and horseradish base and is usually served alongside seafood. It has an earlier history, and though it is not similar to Marie Rose, it’s served the same way.

The US cocktail sauce was also made for the Americans who did not enjoy the British taste and was quite different from the Marie Rose Sauce.

But there is no clear definition of the link between Cradock and Marie Rose. People usually say that the name was obtained from this chef, while others have different variations to justify their results.

Bottom Line

The Thousand island keto is one of the favorite ketogenic salad dressings and is popular among keto lovers. It has great taste, and if I had to choose a favorite salad dressing, I would go with it any day.

It includes my favorite ingredients such as mayonnaise, ketchup, and more which gives it sweetness. Additionally, the other ingredients such as onions and pickles give it the unique taste and preference among many.

But note that the Thousand Island dressing and especially the store-bought is not keto. They usually contain high levels of sugars and saturated fats. If you want keto thousand island dressing, then I recommend you make it at home and limit the use of non-keto-friendly ingredients.

If you want to know more about keto info, please check the following link.

Similar Posts